A prospective study was undertaken of fifty-one patients who were randomly assigned to treatment with either a long or a short thumb-spica cast for a non-displaced fracture of the carpal scaphoid. The duration of follow-up was at least until union; the average follow-up was twelve months. Twenty-eight fractures were treated with a long thumb-spica cast and twenty-three, with a short thumb-spica cast. The hands that initially were treated with a long thumb-spica cast were placed in a short thumb-spica cast after six weeks. Fractures that initially were treated with a long thumb-spica cast united at an average of 9.5 weeks and those that were maintained in a short thumb-spica cast, at an average of 12.7 weeks. There were no non-unions and two delayed unions in the fractures that initially were treated with a long thumb-spica cast, compared with two non-unions and six delayed unions in those that had only a short thumb-spica cast. Fractures of the proximal or middle third of the carpal scaphoid had a significantly shorter time to union when they were treated initially in a long thumb-spica cast. Fractures of the distal third did well regardless of the type of immobilization. On the basis of our results, we recommend an initial period of six weeks of immobilization in a long thumb-spica cast, followed by use of a short thumb-spica cast, for a non-displaced fracture of the proximal or middle third of the carpal scaphoid. This form of treatment resulted in a shorter time to union and a decreased incidence of non-union, without any loss of motion of the elbow.

Full text (sometimes free) may be available at these link(s):      help

• PubMed
• PDF locator
• publisher